From :	HABICHT, Triin <habichtt@who.int>
To :	kgoginashvili <kgoginashvili@moh.gov.ge>; Mamuka Nadareishvili <mamnadar@gmail.com>; EKBERG, Allison <ekberga@who.int>
Subject :	RE: Georgia FP report external review feedback
Cc :	Erica Richardson <Erica.Richardson@lshtm.ac.uk>; DOMENTE, Silviu <domentes@who.int>; THOMSON, Sarah <thomsons@who.int>
Received On :	10.10.2020 06:33
Attachments :	GEO FP report review comments VC LK EA KZ - TH.docx 200928 Review of WHO report on financial protection in Georgia Erik Andermo ST TH.docx Infl_GEO.xlsx

Dear Sarah,

Thank you so much! It’s very encouraging to see that reviewers’ feedback is positive and no major revisions expected.

Dear Keti and Mamuka,

I reviewed the comments and tried to address most of them. Still, couple of comments (highlighted in yellow) would benefit from your inputs. It would be great if you could send your inputs by the end of next week (18 October).

Attached:

the report (with my comments and some edits)
general comments provided by Erik Andermo (with my comments)
data file for cumulative price index

@EKBERG, Allison – I suggest that you could review the report after receiving feedback from Keti and Mamuka.

Have a nice weekend,

Triin

From: THOMSON, Sarah
Sent: Friday, October 9, 2020 4:05 PM
To: kgoginashvili ; Mamuka Nadareishvili ; HABICHT, Triin ; EKBERG, Allison
Cc: Erica Richardson ; DOMENTE, Silviu
Subject: Georgia FP report external review feedback

Dear Keti, Mamuka and Triin

The external review is now complete. We received comments from 5 people, all of them minor.

I am attaching:

the report with comments inserted in the text by Erik Andermo (UN Resident Coordinator Office), Volkan Cetinkaya (World Bank), Lojas Kovacs (EU Delegation) and Kaki Zoidze (Ilia State University)
general comments provided by Erik Andermo (I have added some of my own comments for you)
emails from all of them (for your information only)

In the report, I have addressed some of the comments already. I have left these comments there for you to see but usually marked them as ‘resolved’. I have also commented on some of the comments.

May I suggest that Triin has a first attempt at addressing the remaining comments, calling on Keti, Mamuka and Allison for their input where necessary.

Although it was unusual to ask for comments from so many people, we got some thoughtful feedback from some of the referees and it was useful in terms of raising awareness of the report and its indicators, especially in the EU Delegation and the UN Resident Coordinator’s Office. In fact, Erik Andermo from the UNRCO suggested we include these indicators in the UN Sustainable Development Cooperation Framework – which is what WHO has already recommended to them – so that is a good outcome.

Once the report is finalized, may I also ask Triin and Allison to prepare a first draft of an executive summary for the report, that we can all then review? This should be no more than 800 or so words. You can have a look at recent country reports for examples.

The next steps then will be: share the report with the Ministry for information (after the elections), get the report formally edited (a requirement for the ISBN), prepare a 10-page summary (which will be translated into Georgian) and then publish the report and the summary reports in English and Georgia on the WHO website.

Thanks for this last push and best wishes –

Sarah

Sarah Thomson

Senior Health Financing Specialist

WHO Barcelona Office for Health Systems Strengthening

Can people afford to pay for health care?

New evidence on financial protection in Europe

Also available in Russian + summaries in French, German & Spanish

+34 607 072 924