From : Ekaterine Guntsadze <E.Guntsadze@mof.ge>
To : Tamar Barkalaia <tbarkalaia@moh.gov.ge>
Subject : RE: WB project SP component - follow up questions/clarifications
Cc : Salome Chakvetadze <S.Chakvetadze@mof.ge>; Tamar Gabunia <tgabunia@moh.gov.ge>; Nikoloz Gagua <N.Gagua@mof.ge>; Giorgi Kakauridze <giorgi.kakauridze@mof.ge>
Received On : 08.04.2020 13:50

მადლობა

 

From: Tamar Barkalaia
Sent: ოთხშაბათი, 08 აპრილი, 2020 17:06
To: Ekaterine Guntsadze
Cc: Salome Chakvetadze ; Tamar Gabunia ; Nikoloz Gagua ; Giorgi Kakauridze
Subject: Re: WB project SP component - follow up questions/clarifications

 

ბილო კითხვაზე პასუხში შეგიძლიათ ეს ინფორმაცია გამოიყენოთ:

 

As you know the assessment of households is still carried out in case of their adjustment.  The rating score is calculated on the 30th day after completing the household declaration by the social agent, and the household receives cash benefit  from the second month following the award, but as a temporary measure, SSA has adopted simplified procedures and hence has possibility to genetare the score within 10 days of completing the declaration and transfer benefit from the following month. 

 



On Apr 8, 2020, at 16:52, Ekaterine Guntsadze <e.guntsadze@mof.ge> wrote:



მოგესალმებით,

 

გიგზავნით პასუხებს აქ დასმულ კითხვებზე, გავლილი მაქვს კაკაურიძესთან. გთხოვთ გადახედოთ და ცვლილებების აუცილებლობის შემთხვევაში ჩავასწოროთ, მსოფლიო ბანკის გუნდთან გაგზავნამდე.

 

 

პატივისცემით,

 

ეკა

 

 

ეკატერინე გუნცაძე

საბიუჯეტო დეპარტამენტის უფროსი

საბიუჯეტო დეპარტამენტი

საქართველოს ფინანსთა სამინისტრო

. თბილისი, გორგასლის . #16

 

Ekaterine Guntsadze

Head of Budget Department

Budget Department

Ministry of Finance of Georgia

16 Gorgasali str., Tbilisi, Georgia

e.guntsadze@mof.ge

+995 32 2261 423

+995 577 051 590

 

 

 

From: Maddalena Honorati <mhonorati@worldbank.org>
Sent: ოთხშაბათი, 08 აპრილი, 2020 11:42
To: Ekaterine Guntsadze <E.Guntsadze@mof.ge>; Salome Chakvetadze <S.Chakvetadze@mof.ge>; Tamar Gabunia <tgabunia@moh.gov.ge>; Tamar Barkalaia <tbarkalaia@moh.gov.ge>
Cc: Nikoloz Gagua <N.Gagua@mof.ge>; Volkan Cetinkaya <vcetinkaya@worldbank.org>; nino_moroshkina@yahoo.com; Alicia C. Marguerie <amarguerie@worldbank.org>; Roberto Claudio Sormani <rsormani@worldbank.org>; Lire Ersado <lersado@worldbank.org>; Lela Ghongadze <lghongadze@worldbank.org>
Subject: WB project SP component - follow up questions/clarifications

 

Dear Ms. Guntsadze, Ms.Chakvetadze and Ms. Barkalaia,

 

Many thanks again for the every productive meeting yesterday. We are glad we reached an agreement on the scope of the project. As we are preparing the package of documents for the project , we have the following clarification questions. We understand it is a work in progress and many details are not yet set. To the extent possible we’d appreciate your feedback on the current thinking on the following aspects to inform the costing and implementation arrangements of the project.

 

Thank you in advance for your response. We are of course available for a call, if more convenient.

 

  • Regarding the temporary unemployment benefit for people who are laid-off :
    • We understood that the application for the benefit will be done by employers, who will submit names, bank account details and individuals tax ID number to MOF (or to which agency?).  Please confirm.
    • Do all formal wage workers have a bank account?  if not, how do you plan to transfer the benefit to those who don’t have bank accounts?
    • Which agency/ministry would be responsible for the payment of the benefit? Would there be any extra cost for you associated with the transfer?
    • We understood that incentives to report a false lay-off are little for employers (given the wage subsidy), but is there something planned to verify bank account holders and claims of dismissal?
  • Regarding the retention scheme/w:
    • Based on the income tax database, how many formal wage workers do you have below and above the 750 GEL/month threshold?
    • Could you please confirm that the tax relief will be directly implemented by waiving the 20% income tax on payroll for workers with monthly wages below 750 GEL (and 10% for workers above the 750 GEL threshold)?
    • Please confirm whether the duration will be 4 months as for the temporary unemployment benefit.
    • Will the revenue service apply the tax relief to all registered companies automatically or is it on-demand basis (hence employers have to apply?)?
  • Regarding the one-off/temporary emergency benefit assigned based on the PMT scoring formula:
    • Please confirm how many households are actually receiving ONLY the child benefits based on the registry data as of March 2020) and how many receive both TSA and child benefit.
    • Will the temporary benefit of 200 GEL be added to the social assistance benefits households are already receiving (including the child benefit) or do you envision topping up whatever the household is getting to reach the amount of 200GEL per household? In the latter case, would the 200 cap apply to TSA recipient households?
    • We understand that for the month of April you will use the information already in the registry to assign the emergency benefit (to about 70,000 hh with score between 65,000 and 100,000). For the month of May, applications will be opened for the emergency benefit (in addition to the regular application process for the TSA) using the same application form used to apply to TSA. Is our understanding correct?
    • New applications (those that come in in May) will be assessed and scored according to the existing scoring formula and the emergency benefit assigned to hh with score between 65,000 and 100,000.
    • How long does it take for the household to receive the benefit (number of days between the day the application is submitted to the day the payment is made)?

 

Looking forward to hearing from you

 

Maddalena, on behalf of the team

 

 

 

 

 

Maddalena Honorati

Senior Economist

Social Protection & Labor

T

+1 202 458 1878

E

mhonorati@worldbank.org